HKCF acted as advisor to Stadtwerke Aachen Aktiengesellschaft
The Lübeck energy supplier was unable to convince the municipal supervisory authority in Kiel to approve the buyback. Now Aachen will receive the shares previously held by Dong.
Lübeck. There he sits. In front of a post office somewhere in Denmark. And Lars Hertrampf waits, and has been waiting for hours. The Stadtwerke spokesman checks his watch. Wednesday, shortly before 5 p.m. – and still no call. In his bag is a letter worth EUR 42.3m. It is to be sent by registered mail to the Danish company Dong so that it lands on the executives’ desks punctually at 2 p.m. the next day, when the deadline expires. In it, Stadtwerke Lübeck declares that it is exercising its right of first refusal and intends to buy back the 25.1% stake in the Stadtwerke. But Hertrampf will never post this letter – because at 5:30 p.m. the municipal supervisory authority in Kiel gives the thumbs down. The economic risks of a buyback are too high. So the shares go to Aachen’s municipal utility (Stawag), which is paying Dong EUR 42.3m for them.
Much to the displeasure of the buyback’s supporters. Bruno Böhm (Freie Wähler) described the stop by the municipal supervisory authority as a “death blow to municipal self-government.” The city council had made a “courageous and far-sighted fiscal policy decision, and the state is becoming a stumbling block.” The financing model presented by Lübeck was sound and would have ensured that the city budget benefited from this decision in the long term, Böhm said. The Greens also regret the end of the buyback. “The current low interest rate level offered an opportunity for remunicipalization that will not come again any time soon,” says Silke Mählenhoff of the parliamentary group’s executive committee. Group leader Thorsten Fürter criticized the municipal supervisory authority for describing the city council’s decision of June 20 as surprising: “The city has been debating this intensively and publicly for months. If that has gone unnoticed in Kiel, perhaps they should consider setting up a branch office in Lübeck.” Antje Jansen (Linke) reacted with disappointment and anger. The group chair criticized Mayor Bernd Saxe and Interior Minister Andreas Breitner (both SPD). “Saxe should have campaigned more seriously for the buyback in Kiel,” Jansen said, “and Breitner, as the responsible minister, should have exerted more influence on the municipal supervisory authority to make remunicipalization possible.” The whole affair showed that it had been “a huge mistake to privatize the Stadtwerke.”
Following the CDU, the BfL and the FDP also welcomed Kiel’s decision to stop the deal. “The city’s debt burden is too heavy, the financing risks too incalculable,” says BfL group leader Marcel Niewöhner. The SPD and the Greens in Lübeck had deliberately counted on the red-green state government being unable to approve the deal, thereby leaving the state government with the “blame and responsibility.” Niewöhner: “Not everything that is desirable is also feasible.” FDP group leader Thomas Rathcke: “The financial watchdogs in Kiel are acting far more sensibly than the majorities in the city council.” Aachen’s Stawag was a competent partner “from which Lübeck’s Stadtwerke can learn a great deal.” Until the very end, representatives of the Stadtwerke had tried to convince the municipal supervisory authority in Kiel of their financing concept. On July 1, a meeting took place at the Ministry of the Interior with Stadtwerke Supervisory Board Chairman Claus Möller (SPD), Stadtwerke CEO Stefan Fritz, representatives of the bank engaged by the utility and Mayor Bernd Saxe (SPD). On July 2, the Stadtwerke submitted additional explanations. On July 3 – one day before the deadline – a further statement from the audit firm BDO was received in Kiel. It was above all the BDO reports that tipped the balance. This is evident from the municipal supervisory authority’s conclusion of July 3, which the LN has seen. In a total of four communications, the auditors had made clear that the financing concept presented by Stadtwerke CEO Fritz was not convincing. It did not show beyond doubt that interest and repayment on the EUR 42.3m could be financed. The Hanseatic city had not succeeded in “dispelling the doubts about economic feasibility.”
Stawag stands by its additional offers
Aachen-based energy supplier Stawag has 635 employees and supplies 139,000 customers with electricity. In 2011, the group posted pre-tax profit of EUR 38.8m. Stawag is 100% municipally owned. “We are confident that we can convince the city and the Stadtwerke of the benefits of our partnership,” says Executive Board member Dr. Christian Becker. “And of course we stand by our commitments.” Becker has offered Stadtwerke Lübeck stakes in renewable energy projects. Next, Dong, the seller of the shares, must accept Stawag’s offer; the Federal Cartel Office will then review the acquisition.
Josephine von Zastrow and Kai Dordowsky
Source: Lübecker Nachrichten