Acquisition of the city’s sewer assets by the municipal drainage utility
The city’s sewer network, wastewater treatment plants and pumping stations, which are currently carried as fixed assets on the balance sheet of the municipal budget, are to be acquired by Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb Düsseldorf (SEBD) for a consideration of approximately EUR 599m. The acquisition of the sewer assets will have no impact whatsoever on the current fee calculation for residents. The City Council is to discuss the matter at its meeting on July 13, i.e., before the summer recess. The value of the sewer assets of approximately EUR 599m was determined by an independent external appraiser.
Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb is a municipally owned enterprise with its own economic responsibility. The so-called sewer assets belonged to the municipal budget and were provided to Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb for use and operation. At its budget meeting in December 2016, the City Council resolved that the sewer network currently leased by SEBD is to be acquired by the municipal enterprise and instructed the administration to continue the negotiations already under way to this end. As a result, the assets will in future be economically allocated to the municipal enterprise and placed under its responsibility. From the perspective of the municipal budget, the acquisition price is the more economical option compared with the present value of the lease payments, which decline every year in any case.
Mayor Thomas Geisel: “The current separation between the owner and the user of the sewer network is unnecessary, complicated and unusual. With the acquisition by Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb, what belongs together comes together. The consideration of approximately EUR 599m has been determined objectively and is therefore a fair value, corresponding to the depreciated replacement cost less the third-party grants paid at the time. Nothing changes for fee payers as a result.”
Background
In 2000, the City Council of the state capital of Düsseldorf resolved to convert the municipal wastewater disposal operation into an institution similar to a municipally owned enterprise, effective January 1, 2001. With this resolution, the operation became responsible for its own economic cycle, which is managed outside the municipal budget as a special fund of the municipality. The existing sewer assets, comprising in particular the municipal sewer network, wastewater treatment plants and pumping stations, remained in the municipal budget and have since been provided to the municipal enterprise for use and operation. Since 2001, investments have been made within the economic cycle of Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb.
Düsseldorf: old sewer network to bring EUR 599m to the city’s coffers
At its December meeting, the Düsseldorf City Council gave the green light to sell the city’s old sewer facilities to the current lessee, Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb Düsseldorf (SEBD). The new sewers already belong to SEBD, and Mayor Thomas Geisel said: “What belongs together comes together.” Geisel emphasized that splitting the assets is unusual. City Treasurer Dorothée Schneider welcomes the expected EUR 599m that will be available to her for the 2018 budget.
Underground assets
The municipal sewer network comprises the sewers, wastewater treatment plants and pumping stations. New facilities are already owned by SEBD, while old facilities are leased from the City of Düsseldorf. The municipal budget books EUR 43.5m in lease income for them every year. Due to expiring depreciation, this amount decreases by EUR 2m per year.
A good deal for both sides
Mayor Geisel sees advantages for both sides in the sale. The city can make good use of the money now to finance upcoming investments in school construction. Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb, in turn, builds up assets. Borrowing is favorable in the current interest rate environment; a market test with banks resulted in an interest rate of no more than 1.9%. An auditor confirmed that the value of EUR 599m is based on a realistic estimate (the depreciated replacement cost) and does not impair SEBD’s business capacity. The company retains sufficient funds to make its ongoing investments and to service its existing loans.
The double fee cartwheel
Thomas Geisel emphasized that citizens need not worry about rising fees as a result of the purchase. In the same breath, he pointed out that fees currently cover only 90% of costs. Price increases are therefore likely, but this is independent of the purchase of the sewer network.
Criticism from the CDU
The City Council is to discuss the sale at its meeting on July 13. The CDU opposition criticized the transaction and the communication of the plans. The media were informed before the council’s committees were able to address the matter. This was the wrong order, objected CDU parliamentary group leader Rüdiger Gutt. Deputy group leader Andreas Hartnigk was outraged that Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb was being forced to take out loans for the acquisition. Stadtentwässerungsbetrieb is a municipal enterprise with its own economic responsibility. If SEBD cannot repay its loans, the city is liable. The CDU considers the sale of the sewers economically unwise, as the city forgoes lease income of EUR 500m over the next twenty years.
Geisel and Schneider disagree, considering this option highly economical.