Press release

Karbenn: “Capital requirements of municipal utilities remain high”

Date
August 22, 2017
Location
Cologne
All news

In a volatile market environment, energy utilities face growing challenges in corporate financing. energate spoke with Frank Karbenn, Managing Partner of the advisory firm HKCF Corporate Finance, about rising financial risks and ways to address them.

energate: Mr. Karbenn, a recent study warned of rising financial risks at utilities. How do you assess the financial outlook for municipal utilities?

Karbenn: Where we are talking about the core energy business and there are no ongoing burdens from problematic asset investments, we have seen encouraging results in the recent past. The pillars of the current development are strong customer loyalty and stable revenues from the regulated grid business. Our rating analyses for around 100 municipal utilities, based on published annual financial statements, show a robust “investment grade” for the vast majority of companies. Looking ahead, however, this situation needs to be scrutinized. The pressure on revenues from the grid business is tangible, expectations in the retail business are clouded by skepticism, and earnings in business segments that are already loss-making remain challenging. In addition, persistently high investments combined with increasing debt financing are reflected in rising leverage.

energate: What specific financing challenges do utilities face?

Karbenn: The companies’ capital requirements remain high, but so do the dividend expectations of their municipal owners. In the current capital market environment, municipal utilities are generally in a comfortable position to raise debt capital for financing their core business. Here, the focus is essentially on optimizing financing terms. The bank market is more reluctant when it comes to financing municipal holding companies. Another challenge is broadening access to the capital markets. Municipal utilities are already finding that established financing paths can no longer be taken for granted. The reasons lie in the financing volumes that have accumulated at their relationship banks, combined with a changed risk assessment for utilities. Today, the municipal background is assessed in a much more differentiated way.

energate: How can companies address these challenges?

Karbenn: Cost and process optimization is a recurring challenge in many areas of the business. When it comes to raising debt capital, optimization potential is not exploited with the same rigor. Here, structured and competitive financing processes open up opportunities to identify the right instruments and to finance the often long depreciation cycles on a maturity-matched and optimized basis. In addition, regular analysis of the financial ratios relevant for debt financing creates transparency on the financeability of planned projects. It also provides important insights with regard to the dividend expectations of the municipal owners. Already today, and increasingly in the future, dividend policy will be a key parameter for the financeability of municipal companies.

Rouben Bathke

Source: energate messenger+